appspicks

Is CARROT Weather worth it? Free vs Premium, Ultra and Family

What each CARROT Weather tier unlocks, what it costs, who should pay for Premium or Ultra, and when a free map app like Windy or Ventusky is all you need.

· Editor · · 8 min read

Key takeaways

  • CARROT Weather is worth paying for only if you want radar, widgets, Watch complications or alerts; the free tier handles daily forecast checks.
  • As of November 2026, Premium costs $4.99 a month or $19.99 a year, and it is the right tier for most widget and Apple Watch users.
  • Premium Ultra is for CarPlay drivers and people who want rain, lightning and storm-cell alerts, not for casual users.
  • If you only want radar and forecast maps, free Windy.com or Ventusky does the job without any subscription.
  • All CARROT tiers are subscriptions, Premium Mini is unexplained, and Android pricing has not been confirmed to match iPhone.

Is CARROT Weather worth it? If you check the forecast once a day, the free version is enough, and paying only makes sense once you want radar, widgets, Apple Watch complications or alerts. As of November 2026, Premium costs $4.99 a month or $19.99 a year, while Premium Ultra, at $9.99 a month or $39.99 a year, is mainly for CarPlay drivers and people who want rain and lightning alerts.

CARROT Weather is a polished forecast app with a sarcastic personality, and it has won Apple's App of the Year, an Apple Design Award and Editors' Choice. If all you really want is a good look at the radar, free map apps like Windy.com and Ventusky cover that without a subscription. Below is what each tier unlocks, what it costs and who should pay.

The short answer, tier by tier

Prices below are US App Store figures reported by reviewers and the App Store listing, as of November 2026.

TierPriceWhat it addsWho should pay
Free$0Current conditions, hourly and daily forecast, the personalityAnyone who checks the weather once a day
Premium$4.99/month or $19.99/yearRadar, other data sources, most notifications, widgets, Watch complications, no adsWidget and Apple Watch users
Premium Ultra$9.99/month or $39.99/yearRain, lightning and storm-cell alerts, CarPlay app, super-res radar, maps widgetDrivers and people who track storms
Premium Family$14.99/month or $59.99/yearEverything in Ultra, shared with up to five peopleHouseholds with several Apple users
Premium Mini$0.99/month or $6.99/year (listed)Not publicly explainedCheck the in-app paywall first

Every paid tier is an auto-renewing subscription. There is no one-time purchase that unlocks the app for good, which matters if you dislike recurring charges.

What the free version gives you

The free download is a complete forecast app, not a demo. You get current conditions, an hourly forecast and a daily outlook, all delivered with CARROT's commentary. You can also pick one of five personalities, ranging from professional to a setting the app calls overkill.

For someone who opens a weather app in the morning to decide on a jacket, that covers the job. Digital Trends reached the same conclusion in its iPhone weather app roundup, saying the free tier is fine for once-a-day checks.

What is missing without paying

The gaps are the features most people associate with a serious weather app:

  • Radar. Reviewers list radar maps as a paid feature.
  • All notifications. Precipitation, severe weather and lightning alerts need a subscription.
  • Widgets. Every Home Screen and Lock Screen widget requires Premium.
  • Apple Watch complications. These are also Premium only.
  • Other data sources. The free tier sticks with the default forecast provider.

If any of those is the reason you installed the app, the free tier will feel thin quickly.

Are there ads in the free tier?

This is murkier than it should be. The App Store describes Premium as ad-free, which implies the free tier shows something. Digital Trends, on the other hand, describes the free version as having no real ads, and one user on a review site complained about fake advertisements. In practice, expect prompts and in-app promotions nudging you toward a subscription rather than heavy third-party banners.

What Premium unlocks

Premium is the tier most people should consider first. According to the App Store listing, it adds extra data sources, notifications, deeper customisation, widgets and Apple Watch complications, and it removes ads.

A few details are worth knowing before you subscribe:

  • Notifications: Premium unlocks the notification system, but some types, including precipitation and custom data point alerts, are reserved for Ultra.
  • Widgets: you get every Home Screen and Lock Screen widget except the Weather Maps widget, which is Ultra only. That includes the Snark widget, which pairs a short-term forecast with a sarcastic line.
  • Customisation: you can rearrange the interface and choose which data appears where.
  • Watch: complications put the forecast on your watch face.

Data sources you can switch to

CARROT uses Foreca by default. Premium members can switch to Apple Weather, AccuWeather, Tomorrow.io, OpenWeather or Xweather. Regional providers are also listed, including Environment Canada, Deutscher Wetterdienst, MeteoFrance, MET Norway and WillyWeather.

If you own a WeatherFlow Tempest or Netatmo station, CARROT can read from those too. Being able to pick the provider that is most accurate where you live is one of the better arguments for paying.

What Ultra and Family add

Premium Ultra

Ultra includes everything in Premium, then adds the features aimed at people who need to react to weather quickly:

  • Rain, lightning and storm-cell notifications, where available
  • A CarPlay app
  • Super-res radar
  • The Weather Maps widget
  • Quick switching between data sources

The official support FAQ also mentions forecasts in the Locations tab and individual US radar stations as Ultra features. Treat the App Store list above as the current reference, since some third-party reviews describe Ultra features that do not appear in CARROT's own wording.

Pricing is less tidy than it looks. Most sources quote $9.99 a month or $39.99 a year, but the App Store purchase list also shows Ultra at $7.99 and $29.99. Those may be introductory offers or other billing options; nobody has explained them publicly.

Premium Family

Family is Ultra for a household. It includes everything in Ultra and can be shared with up to five family members through Apple Family Sharing, at $14.99 a month or $59.99 a year as of November 2026. If two or more people in your home would otherwise pay for Ultra, Family is the cheaper route.

The unexplained Premium Mini

The App Store purchase list includes a CARROT Premium Mini at $0.99 a month or $6.99 a year. Neither the App Store description nor the support FAQ explains what it includes, and paywall trackers describe it only as a third tier name. If you see it offered, read the in-app paywall carefully to see which features it covers before choosing it over full Premium.

What CARROT costs over time

The yearly plans are where the value is. Monthly Premium works out to about $60 a year, three times the annual price. One competitor's comparison put three years of Premium at about $60 on the yearly plan and about $180 on the monthly plan.

Ultra on the yearly plan comes to roughly $120 over three years. Before committing, use the 7-day free trial to see which features you actually open. A practical approach:

  • Start the trial on Premium, not Ultra.
  • Add the widgets and Watch complications you would really use.
  • Upgrade to Ultra only if you miss rain alerts or CarPlay during the trial.
  • Pick the yearly plan if you keep it.

Is CARROT Weather worth it for you? A verdict by user type

The honest answer depends on how you use a weather app.

  • You check once a day. Stay on the free tier. The forecast, hourly view and personality are all there.
  • You live in widgets or on an Apple Watch. Premium is the tier for you. Widgets and complications are the main reason to pay, and the yearly plan is reasonable for something you glance at many times a day.
  • You drive a lot with CarPlay. Ultra is the only tier with the CarPlay app, so it is the obvious pick if you want weather on your car's screen.
  • You need storm, rain or lightning alerts. Ultra again. Those down-to-the-minute alerts are the feature that justifies the higher price.
  • You mostly want radar and forecast maps. Do not pay yet. A free map app may do everything you need, as the next section explains.

So, is CARROT Weather worth it overall? For widget and Watch users, Premium on the yearly plan is a fair deal. Ultra is a specialist upgrade, not the default.

When free Windy or Ventusky radar is enough

Many people consider paying for CARROT just to see where the rain is heading. If that is you, try a free map app first. We compare the two main options in detail in Windy vs Ventusky, and you can browse more in our Weather category.

Windy.com

Windy's web and app versions are free and ad-free. You get more than 50 map layers, several forecast models and webcams, which makes it excellent for wind, waves, sailing and outdoor planning.

The main limit is time resolution. Since January 2023, the free plan steps through the forecast in 3-hour intervals, and the 1-hour view requires Windy Premium, which starts at £2.99 on the UK App Store. Note that Windy.app is a separate company from Windy.com.

Ventusky

Ventusky gives you full map access free and without ads. It lets you choose between weather models and has layers for aviation temperatures, snow depth, thunderstorms and waves, with a timeline running about ten days ahead. An optional paid tier adds higher-resolution animation.

What map apps will not do

Windy and Ventusky are map apps. They are not built to replace CARROT's alerts, widgets or personality.

NeedCARROT WeatherWindy.comVentusky
Free animated mapsNo (radar is paid)Yes, ad-freeYes, ad-free
Model comparisonSwitch data sources on PremiumSeveral modelsChoice of models
Rain and lightning alertsUltraNot the focusNot the focus
Widgets and Watch complicationsPremiumNot the focusNot the focus
CarPlayUltraNoNo
PlatformsiOS, Android, Mac, Apple WatchWeb, iOS, AndroidWeb, iOS, Android

A sensible free setup is your phone's built-in weather app for daily checks plus Windy or Ventusky for radar. Pay for CARROT only when you want those features in one place, delivered to your wrist or Lock Screen.

Platforms and the Android question

CARROT runs on iPhone, iPad, Apple Watch and Android. On a Mac, the iOS app installs from the iPhone and iPad Apps tab in the Mac App Store. The iOS version also supports Lock Screen widgets and Live Activities.

Android users should be cautious with the details above. Almost every review covers the iPhone version, and nobody has confirmed whether Android tiers and prices match. Family, as described, relies on Apple Family Sharing, so check the paywall in the Google Play version before subscribing.

Other options worth a look

A few apps not listed on AppsPicks come up often in this comparison:

  • Apple Weather is the free default on iPhone and is good enough for many people. It is also one of the data sources CARROT Premium can use.
  • Hello Weather is a simpler app with a single Pro tier, a good fit if you want a clean forecast without the jokes.
  • RadarScope is a paid radar tool built for storm chasers. If radar is the only reason you would buy Ultra, it is worth comparing.

If you like reading about whether a subscription pays off, our take on Geocaching Premium follows the same free-versus-paid logic, and our list of the best utility apps covers more everyday tools.

Frequently asked questions

Is CARROT Weather free to use?

Yes. The free version gives you current conditions, an hourly forecast, a daily outlook and the sarcastic commentary. Radar, notifications, widgets and Apple Watch complications need a paid tier.

Can you buy CARROT Weather once instead of subscribing?

No. All paid tiers are auto-renewing subscriptions, and there is no one-time purchase. The yearly plans are the cheapest way to pay, and a 7-day free trial lets you test Premium first.

Does CARROT Weather work with CarPlay or Apple Watch without paying?

Not fully. Apple Watch complications require Premium, and the CarPlay app is only included in Premium Ultra and Premium Family.

What is CARROT Premium Mini?

It is a subscription that appears in the App Store purchase list at $0.99 a month or $6.99 a year. CARROT has not published what it includes, so check the in-app paywall before choosing it.

Is Windy or Ventusky good enough instead of paying for a weather app?

For radar and forecast maps, often yes. Both are free and ad-free, but they do not offer CARROT-style alerts, widgets, Watch complications or CarPlay.

Is Premium Ultra worth it over regular Premium?

Only if you want rain, lightning and storm-cell alerts, the CarPlay app, super-res radar or the Weather Maps widget. For widgets and Watch complications alone, regular Premium is enough.

Apps in this article

Sources

  1. CARROT Weather: Alerts & Radar on the App Store
  2. CARROT Weather Support
  3. I tested over 20 iPhone weather apps for a month - Digital Trends
  4. What CARROT Weather costs - AppMatchup
  5. A mobile paywall by Carrot Weather with Adapty
  6. Cloudmesh Weather vs CARROT Weather (2026)
  7. Windy Review - Dailystoke
  8. Best Windy.com alternatives in 2026 - Unstore

Last updated Nov 21, 2026. Prices and features were checked at the time of writing.

Articles on AppsPicks are researched and drafted with AI from current sources, checked automatically before publishing, and corrected by our editor when something is wrong. Spotted a mistake? Email [email protected]. How we review

Read in: EspañolPortuguês (Brasil)DeutschРусский